Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Final comments on the Roundtable on Science, Strategy and War

Col/Dr. Franz Osinga has posted a reply to the online reviews of his book Science, Strategy and War. He offered kind words for the review and commented that the United States is the best place for open discussions to take place. He went on to share the problems he had understanding John Boyd. The article is posted on zenpunidt.com Osinga Roundtable on Science, Strategy and War: The Author’s Reply and Chicago Boyz .

It was a pleasure to participate in this discussion and read the comments of the other participants. This type of forum, held online holds promise for future discussions. No great decision was reached, and I doubt if anyone's mind was changed by any of the arguments. But everyone gained by reading the thoughts of others on the same subject.

This intersection of views gives purchase to a new tool with which to discuss the revelevant topics of the day. A sort of Junto society if you will, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Junto where in 1727 Benjamin Franklin founded a society to discuss the issues of the day. The Junto's Friday evening meetings were organized around a series of questions that Franklin devised, covering a range of intellectual, personal, business, and community topics. These questions were used as a springboard for discussion and community action. In fact, through the Junto, Franklin promoted such concepts as volunteer fire-fighting clubs, improved security (night watchmen), and a public hospital.

Ever since I began to read blogs and now write my own, I am struck with the similarities of the original intent of Franklin's group and the online blog community today. Another point that todays blog community has with American history is the similar tone and function of the blogs, in relationship to the prevalence of pamplets, extolling the virtues and vices of life under the British. Much has been made by historians, that this grass roots element was insturmental in uplifting the American spirit towards revolution, by the reading of thousands of pamplets in taverns every night.

Today's blogs instead of talking of revolution, are formulating revolutionary thinking, where new ideas are given an intersection to meet, and reasonable men and women can offer thought and comment, in order to find new innovations for the challenges that confront us.

2 comments:

Dan tdaxp said...

If the roundtable is published in dead tree media, my vote is to use this as the afterword

historyguy99 said...

Thanks, Dan